Make a Payment Online

Company Payment Links

The insurance carriers listed below may accept credit card or electronic check payments. Please click on your appropriate carrier below. If you cannot find your appropriate company payment link below, please feel free to contact us directly.

American Modern Insurance Group Payment methods: check, debit card, Visa, MasterCard, American Express & Discover. No fee to pay online or by phone. Pay by phone: 800.543.2644. Pay by mail: P.O. Box 5323, Cincinnati, OH 45201
Dairyland Insurance Payment methods: check, debit card, Visa & MasterCard. No fee to pay by phone. Pay by phone: 800.532.2525. Pay by mail: P.O. Box 8021, Stevens Point, WI 53001.
Encompass Insurance Payment methods: check, debit card, Visa, MasterCard, American Express & Discover. No fee to pay online or by phone. Pay by phone: 866.430.2916. Pay by mail: P.O. Box 3576, Akron, OH 44309.
Erie Insurance Payment methods: check, debit card, Visa, MasterCard, American Express & Discover. No fee to pay online with Visa, MasterCard or e-check; $5 fee for American Express, Discover and payments by phone. Pay by phone: 800.387.1492. Pay by mail: 100 Erie Insurance Place, Erie, PA 16530.
Eastern Alliance Insurance Group Payment methods: check. No online or phone payment options. Pay by mail: P.O. Box 206, East Petersburg, PA 17520.
Foremost Insurance Group Payment methods: check, debit card, Visa & MasterCard. No fee to pay online or by phone. Pay by phone: 800.532.4221. Pay by mail: P.O. Box 3333, Grand Rapids, MI 49501.
Foremost Distinct/Bristol West Payment methods: check, debit card, Visa & MasterCard. No fee to pay online or by phone. Pay by phone: 888.888.0080 (press 2 for Billing). Pay by mail: P.O. Box 371329, Pittsburgh, PA 15250.
Frederick Mutual Payment methods: check, debit card, Visa & MasterCard. No fee to pay online or by phone. Pay by phone: 800.544.8737. Pay by mail: 57 Thomas Johnson Drive, Frederick, MD 21705.
Grange Insurance Payment methods: check, debit card, Visa, MasterCard & Discover. No fee to pay online or by phone. Pay by phone: 800.425.1100. Pay by mail: P.O. Box 740604, Cincinnati, OH 45274. Enroll in EFT program: https://www.grangeinsurance.com/easy-pay
The Hartford Insurance Payment methods: check, debit card, credit card. Pay by phone: 866.467.8730. Enroll in mobile applications for your smartphone: https://www.thehartford.com/mobile-tools
Harford Mutual Payment methods: check, debit card, credit card. Pay by phone: 1.855.590.2456. Pay by mail: P.O. Box 62434, Baltimore, MD 21264.
Main Street America Group Payment methods: check, debit card, Visa, MasterCard & Discover. $4.95 fee to pay online or by phone. Pay by phone: 800.611.0958. Pay by mail: P.O. Box 2004, Keene, NH 03431. Enroll in EFT program: http://www.msagroup.com/policyholder/Policyholder%20EFT%20Authorization%20Form.pdf
Progressive Insurance Payment methods: check, debit card, Visa, MasterCard & Discover. No fee to pay online or by phone. Pay by phone: 877.776.2436.
Safeco Insurance Payment methods: check, debit card, Visa, MasterCard, American Express & Discover. No fee to pay online or by phone. Pay by phone: 800.332.3226. Pay by mail: P.O. Box 6476, Carol Stream, IL 60197.
Travelers Insurance Payment methods: check, debit card, Visa, MasterCard & Discover. No fee to pay online or by phone. Pay by phone: 800.842.5075. Pay by mail: P.O. Box 660307, Dallas, TX 75266.
Westfield Insurance Group Payment methods: check, debit card, Visa & MasterCard. $5.95 fee to pay online or by phone. Pay by phone: 800.766.9133. Pay by mail: P.O. Box 9001566, Louisville, KY 40290. Enroll in EFT program: http://media.westfieldinsurance.com/www//billing/0411_0511_eftForm.pdf